September 15th, 2011 1:00am
Undelivered Letters Written Years Ago
Slow Club “You, Earth or Ash”
The first few times I listened to this song it didn’t register beyond the lovely harmony hook in the chorus, but as I’ve become more acquainted, it’s revealed itself to be one of the most moving, gorgeous and well-constructed pop songs that I’ve encountered this year. Every sound and texture in this stark, minimal arrangement is careful and thoughtfully deployed, but it’s not stuffy or overworked. It’s organic and loose, with all the sounds framing Rebecca Taylor’s vocal performance, which is so nuanced in its phrasing that tiny inflections convey volumes of emotional subtext. The text is gutting enough as it is – she’s singing about knowing that her close connection to someone is going to end one way or another – but the mature musical decisions made at every moment in this piece result in something incredibly moving.
Buy it from Amazon.