We’ve Got A Secret Between Us

I should know by now that the Fiery Furnaces are never going to do anything the “normal” way. I had assumed that when the band got around to releasing a live album, it would be very simple: Each tour has a different line-up of instruments and/or musicians, and corresponding arrangements and medleys, so they could just release a disc from each period. Blueberry Boat medley tour? Check. Four-piece hard rock combo circa 2006? Got it. Groovy keyboard-centric combo, circa now? Rad! But no, they went another way, and shock of all shocks, it’s unlike any other official live record that I’ve ever encountered. Remember is less like a document, and more like an audio documentary that culls recordings of various sound quality from a range of shows and cuts it all into a very odd sort of mixtape.

Weird things about Remember:

1. As I said, the audio is of varying quality. That would be strange enough, but several songs cut back and forth between very nice, professional audio, and clips that sound as though they were taken from a B+ audience bootleg recording. It’s extremely jarring at first, but in some cases, it has an interesting dynamic effect, and keeps the listener aware of context.

2. Though the band is known for performing medleys, several of the medleys on Remember were created in post-production. In some cases, it’s a matter of keeping the flow through the record. In others, such as the string of Widow City fragments at end of disc 2, it’s just baffling, especially since “Navy Nurse,” “Philadelphia Grand Jury,” and “Clear Signal From Cairo” have only ever been performed in full to the best of my knowledge.

3. There are totally frustrating cuts. The most egregious example is “Chief Inspector Blancheflower,” which starts off with the typical art-punk version of the opening section, before having the second section start and cut off immediately and gracelessly clunk into the seldom-performed “bakery” section of the piece. This is a totally maddening thing, especially since the second and third parts of the song are the crowd-pleasers.

4. A majority of the album is taken from the band’s worst period as a live band, i.e. the 2007 Bitter Tea tour with the extra percussion. Granted, a lot of that stuff comes across better on this album, but that doesn’t change the fact that many of the older songs performed on that tour were butchered horribly. Seriously, whenever I hear this version of “Name Game,” I wonder how it is that they were able to take one of my favorite songs in the world and make me hate it. However, I didn’t have any nicely recorded shows from that tour, but I do have top-quality recordings of every other era, so maybe they were just trying to fill a gap there?

5. They make Frankenstein versions of the longer songs.

The Fiery Furnaces “Blueberry Boat” (Remember version) – For example! Though it is a multi-part song, the band only ever performs the verses of “Blueberry Boat” that are sung by Eleanor on the album. This epic version of the song is in fact composed of bits and pieces of the song in slightly differing arrangements from various shows. You can really get a sense of the varying sound qualities in this track, especially since you’re essentially hearing the same thing over and over, but from different takes. It holds together as a track with its own internal logic pretty well, but it’s still quite bizarre and questionable. I mean, it sounds more like something an obsessed fan would make, and less like the opening track of a double live album.

The Fiery Furnaces “Forty-Eight Twenty-Three Twenty-Second Street” (Remember version) – The most exciting and enjoyable section of Remember is its run of radically re-arranged numbers from Rehearsing My Choir. In concert, the band tends to downplay the spoken word sections of the songs, and emphasize the grooves that were often only implied in the album arrangements. Some of the make-overs are so drastic that the songs are nearly unrecognizable compared to their studio incarnations: “Forty-Eight Twenty-Three Twenty-Second Street” has so many elements added or removed that it may as well be considered a new (and superior) draft of the composition.

(Click here to pre-order it from Thrill Jockey, or buy it at the merch stand on the band’s current tour.)