The Only Vote That Matters
R.E.M. @ Madison Square Garden 11/04/2004
It’s The End Of The World As We Know It (And I Feel Fine) / Begin The Begin / So Fast, So Numb / Animal / Boy In The Well / Welcome To The Occupation / The Outsiders / Get Up / High Speed Train / Cuyahoga / Sweetness Follows / The One I Love / I Wanted To Be Wrong / Imitation Of Life / Final Straw / Losing My Religion / Walk Unafraid / Life And How To Live It // What’s The Frequency, Kenneth? / Drive / Leaving New York / Electrolite / Permanent Vacation / I’m Gonna DJ (new song, “death is pretty final, I’m collecting vinyl, I’m gonna DJ at the end of the world!”) / Man On The Moon
R.E.M. “I Wanted To Be Wrong” – R.E.M. has become my stock answer whenever anyone asks me to name the least cool band that I love. It seems that no one wants to admit that they like them anymore, and if they do, they feel the need to qualify themselves: “They were good up until ________.” I don’t think that R.E.M. has ever stopped being a great band, though the post-Bill Berry material has been the least consistent period of their career to date.
There’s a few good reasons for this. For one, their sense of quality control has diminished, resulting in overlong records padded out with filler. Up would have been more successful if it ended after 40 minutes, and Around The Sun could’ve been a very tight record if trimmed back to nine cuts. Reveal, the weakest album in their catalog, could’ve been an excellent EP.
The second big problem, which is made tremendously obvious when the newer songs are performed live, is that they’ve been producing their records very badly. They strip away the physical immediacy of the songs and bury everything under the icy gloss of infinite overdubs. “The Outsiders” and “High Speed Train” sound bland and uninspired on record, but come alive with percussive oomph and Sonic Youth-worthy guitar noise in their live incarnations. Not much can keep either song from rising above competant mediocrity, but at least they aren’t neutered and cringe-inducing. If I could pick the producer for the next record, it would be Spoon’s Britt Daniel and Jim Eno, who are extremely gifted at recording dynamic, clean, unfussy rock records. In particular, the sound that they get on their percussion is exactly what R.E.M. need post-Berry – a backbeat that feels urgent and alive.
The third problem is less obvious, and somewhat theoretical. Though I’m not sure if I even agree with this idea anymore, a strong case can be made that Michael Stipe’s lyrical narrative has played itself out. It’s not hard to trace the evolution of Stipe’s character over the course of his career, even if he (somewhat accurately) insists that he rarely writes from a confessional point of view. He begins as a shy young man prone to mumbling obtuse lyrics and suffering from “conversation fear”, but over the course of the IRS period, he transforms himself into a bombastic sloganeering political activist. He gradually develops the courage to write proper love songs, confront his mortality, express his sexuality, and openly examine his personal relationships. The progress seems to come to a natural conclusion with “Walk Unafraid”, in which Stipe emerges as a confident, emotionally mature adult who accepts himself and is finally “prepared to look you in the eye.” That song earns its sense of triumph – I have no doubt that it is the very real culmination of the arc of one man’s progress in dealing with his insecurity. The problem is, if part of the appeal of R.E.M. is based on the cult of personality surrounding Michael Stipe, the dramatic tension is lost somewhat if we’re dealing with this charming, plain spoken metrosexual rather than the earnest if incoherant persona which characterized the band’s classic material. Though present day Stipe is affable and inspiring, his current lyrics seem as though he’s writing his own fan fic – The Further Adventures Of R.E.M., as it were.
This is why it’s a good thing that R.E.M. are returning to writing overtly political music – they can enter into a context that doesn’t have to involve Michael the persona, but can capitalize on Stipe’s new fondness for clear, declarative language. When Stipe introduced “I Wanted To Be Wrong” last night at Madison Square Garden, he said that it was one of the few songs that he’s ever written sung directly from his point of view. Though I tend to distrust that statement, I believe that bit of information lends some extra power to the song, in which the singer attempts to understand the perspective and culture of the “red states,” but is frustrated when he cannot. It’s probably the best expression of an idea which is both personal and political in his entire career, and hints at a direction which does in fact move beyond the emotional resolution of “Walk Unafraid.” (Click here to buy it from Amazon.)
R.E.M. “Begin The Begin (live in Germany, 2003)” – The show last night was both fun (a lot of upbeat numbers, fewer ballads and mid-tempo tracks than on previous tours) and cathartic. Stipe barely talked at all over the course of the show (which is sort of amazing if you’ve seen them play at all in the past five years), later explaining that he didn’t know what to say, and was electing to let the music do the talking. As a result, the setlist was very lyrically driven, focusing on material relevant to recent events. “It’s The End Of The World As We Know It (And I Feel Fine)” seemed to express the band’s mission statement for the night and was an excellent and truly surprising opener (in the sense that the song had not yet been played on this tour and is traditionally the final song of the night). In terms of the song’s prescient lyrics and the band’s raw enthusiasm, “Begin The Begin” sounded as though it could’ve been written yesterday.
The audience were mostly quite lame. Most of the people in my section opted to hit the bathrooms and the concession stands whenever they played a song from Around The Sun (I don’t understand why people like this go to see music events, especially expensive ones at big venues.) Almost everyone flipped out when they played “The One I Love,” “Losing My Religion,” and “What’s The Frequency, Kenneth?,” yet classics like “Get Up” and “Life And How To Live It” were met with only small pockets of enthusiasm. Stipe introduced “Cuyahoga” as a song taking place in Ohio, which resulted in loud booing from all over the arena. Still, there was loud applause every time he sang the line “let’s put our heads together and start a new country up,” which was more reassuring. On my way out of the arena, I overheard two guys who looked like ex-frat dudes talk about how great it was that Michael didn’t talk much because they can’t stand “liberal whining.” Sigh. A few minutes later, I saw a cute girl in a bright orange t-shirt with homemade lettering which read “I’ve got my spine, I’ve got my Orange Crush,” which kinda sorta cancelled out those goons. (Click here to buy it from Amazon.)
Also: If you happen to be in the NYC area this weekend, I strongly encourage you to go to the WFMU Record Fair, which is at the Metropolitan Pavilion, located at 125 West 18th Street, just off of 6th Avenue. The Fair is open for regular admission ($5) on Friday from 7-10 PM, and on Saturday and Sunday from 10 AM – 7 PM.